Tuesday, September 8, 2009

Response to Iranian Confession

The story which Omid Memarian told about his forced confessions while imprisoned in Iran is one of the most disturbing stories I have ever heard. I could not imagine being in such a sensitive and frightening situation. The men who were holding him captive repeatedly beat him and threatened him, saying that they would keep him as a prisoner until he confessed to a false story. Memarian’s interrogator took his true story and incorporated fake names and places. Not only did he have to write out these “confessions,” but they also had to broadcast them across mediums such as television and/or radio.

Memarian is obviously not the only victim in Iran of this kind, as we often see many of these cases on local news programs. The alarming aspect about it, though, is the fact that every recent forced confession has been about the same thing. One of the major similarities between these falsified admissions is the mentioning of certain international figures and institutions. Scenarios such as these have become so repetitive and absurd in Iran that a native stand-up comedian had an act which revolved around them; he was soon after deported and kicked out of the country.

We must somehow stand up to Iran and cease all related activities, and although it is a delicate situation, a strategy must be devised. We cannot permit these terrible occurrences to continue.

-Scott Hyman

Some Class Responses to This American Life podcast

Even though the security force did their best to make the confessions look unforced, the sheer number of almost identical confessions should create enough suspicion that no one in the right mind should even remotely believe what is in the confessions. Also the officials that were getting these reports and said they had no idea that they were coerced are most likely lying. I would hope that someone who is in a high enough position of power to be seeing the written copy of these confessions would be intelligent enough to see the pattern in the confessions and question their validity.
--
ROOSA,MICHAEL T

The story of the Iranian???s false confession was both shocking and overwhelming. I was aware that things of this nature happen frequently in foreign countries, but it was much different to hear from a personal account. I cannot imagine having to fake a detailed confession, especially while being interrogated and beaten. I believe it takes an extremely strong-willed individual to withstand the pain and suffering and write pages and pages about something that never happened, while knowing that after this confession is released his/her life will change dramatically. Personally, I have a hard time admitting to things I actually do, so I don???t think I could ever admit to something that I didn???t do. If admitting to a false confession would mean my career could possibly end, or that I might be forced to leave the country in which I reside, I don???t think I could bring myself to write it. I am thankful that I live in a country in which our government is fair and does not force people against their will to make false confessions.

Sara Sanfilippo

After listening to the radio story about the Iranian torture, I find myself very happy to live in the United States. I knew that tapings of false testimony against other cultures and media outlets were broadcast to the general public, but it is especially upsetting to hear about through a first hand account. I was very surprised that the reporter said the government was unaware of the forced confessions, however, I don't necessarily believe the word of any Iranian government official. The worst part of the story for me was the lack of protection of the man as a journalist and also as a citizen. I hope the people in Iran can rise above their oppressive government and live more freely and happily, but right now the people are very brain-washed and have restricted knowledge of many facts about their government.

Sincerely,
Kate Livanec

Week Three Revised from Original Syllabus

Monday, September 7th
  • Listen to This American Life and email your teacher a reaction/post a comment on this blog
Wednesday, September 9th
Friday, September 11th
  • Discuss international law with respect to terrorism and American foreign policy reaction to events and aftermath of September 11, 2001
    • Topics to consider
      • United Nations Security Council and American invasion of and intervention in Afghanistan
      • Outcome of War on Terror including enemy combatants and American imprisonment
      • Discussion of Guantanamo Bay detainees and denial of habeas corpus rights based on foreign jurisdiction
      • Discussion of Torture

Additional Reading, NYTimes Op-ed Piece by FBI Agent

This article is from Sunday's paper, very interesting.

Adding Blog Comments

For this week, please email me a short reaction to the radio program, preferably about our Iranian prisoner, and I'll post the replies myself. See you tomorrow!

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Clarification for Legal Brief One Assignment

Class, I understand I have been contradictory regarding Friday's assignment. Initially, I said you had to do this on negligence, and then today I told you that this paper was on emotional distress. You can write your brief on either cause of action. If you have further questions, please email me. See you all Friday!

Legal Brief Example

Class,

Here is an example of a legal brief; you may want to use this as an example:


http://web.clas.ufl.edu/users/cgreer/Law/LAWiracbrief.html